A Surging Tide in the Banking Sector
The Indian banking sector has found itself in the spotlight once again, with the shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank surging to record highs. As the fourth quarter results approach, investors are buzzing with anticipation, wondering—which stock is the better bet moving forward?
Thursday’s market session was a dramatic one. With both HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank stocks climbing to all-time highs, the Bank Nifty index outperformed even the prestigious Nifty 50, making it a landmark day in financial history. But what’s fueling this momentum? Is it pure speculation, or do the fundamentals back it up?
Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank: Record High Levels Before Q4 Results
HDFC Bank shares ticked up by 1.07%, landing at ₹1,898.00 on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE). Simultaneously, ICICI Bank gained 2.01%, reaching ₹1,384.05—a new record.
This sharp rise comes just days ahead of the announcement of Q4 FY25 results, expected on Saturday, April 19. With markets shut on Friday, April 18, investors had just one day to reposition their holdings. Naturally, this created a buying frenzy.
April 19: The Crucial Date for HDFC and ICICI Bank Shareholders
Mark your calendars. April 19, 2025, isn’t just another date—it’s D-Day for investors in India’s largest private banks. The earnings reports will provide insights into margins, profitability, and asset quality.
Investors who took positions prior to this could either be handsomely rewarded or left biting their nails, depending on how the financials pan out.
What Do Analysts Expect from HDFC Bank’s Q4FY25 Earnings?
Market experts suggest HDFC Bank’s net profit and Net Interest Income (NII) are poised to grow. However, there’s a looming caveat—pressure on operating margins.
Here’s a quick projection table:
| Financial Metric | Expected YoY Growth |
|---|---|
| Net Profit | 11.5% |
| Net Interest Income | 9.8% |
| Net Interest Margin | Slight decline |
While growth is anticipated, it may not be as aggressive due to elevated credit costs and merger-related integration issues post its acquisition of HDFC Ltd.
ICICI Bank’s Forecast: Strong Margins and Profit Upside
Unlike HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank seems to have the wind at its back. Analysts are forecasting a 12.3% rise in net profit, with NII expected to grow by 9.2%.
| Financial Metric | Expected YoY Growth |
|---|---|
| Net Profit | 12.3% |
| Net Interest Income | 9.2% |
| Net Interest Margin | Stable to improving |
Notably, ICICI Bank has kept a strong grip on its retail loan book and improved asset quality, giving it a strong edge in terms of profitability.
Comparing Business Models: HDFC Bank vs ICICI Bank
Let’s dig into the DNA of both these banking giants:
| Feature | HDFC Bank | ICICI Bank |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Retail & Corporate | Retail & Digital |
| Digital Adoption | Moderate | High |
| NPAs (Gross) | 1.26% | 0.90% |
| ROE (Return on Equity) | ~16% | ~17.5% |
ICICI Bank’s aggressive push into digital banking and better asset quality have made it more appealing for short- to medium-term investors.
Recent Performance of Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank
HDFC Bank has given a YTD return of 8%, while ICICI Bank has outpaced it with a 12% return. These numbers become even more significant when you compare them with the benchmark Nifty 50, which rose approximately 5.4% YTD.
Bank Nifty vs Nifty 50: Who Led the Rally?
Thanks to HDFC and ICICI Bank’s stellar performance, the Bank Nifty has been stealing the show. On Thursday, it outperformed Nifty 50, closing with a sharp upside.
Reasons for Outperformance:
- Pre-result buying
- Improved economic indicators
- Lower NPAs
- Stable interest rate outlook
Investment Strategies: Long-Term vs Short-Term Goals
If you’re in it for the long haul, HDFC Bank might still be a safer play due to its stronger retail deposit base and historical performance. However, ICICI Bank looks more agile and growth-oriented for short- to mid-term gains.
Technical Indicators: Bullish or Overbought?
Let’s break down what the charts say:
HDFC Bank:
- RSI: 68 (approaching overbought)
- 50-DMA: Strong support at ₹1,840
- MACD: Bullish crossover
ICICI Bank:
- RSI: 71 (overbought zone)
- 50-DMA: Support at ₹1,350
- MACD: Extremely bullish
Key Catalysts Driving Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank
Here’s what’s pushing the rally:
- Strong Q4 expectations
- Improving credit quality
- Higher retail loan disbursals
- Robust earnings outlook
- Favorable interest rate environment
Market Sentiment: What Are Big Investors Saying?
According to multiple brokerages, including Motilal Oswal, Kotak Securities, and CLSA, both banks remain “Buy” rated.
“ICICI Bank’s digital-led growth model is exemplary,” — CLSA
“HDFC Bank will bounce back post-merger hiccups,” — Kotak Securities
Dividend Yields: A Deciding Factor?
| Bank | Dividend Yield |
|---|---|
| HDFC Bank | ~1.1% |
| ICICI Bank | ~0.9% |
HDFC slightly edges out ICICI in this department. For income-focused investors, this could be a minor tipping point.
Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank Reached All-Time High, Which One is Expected to Give Higher Returns on Investment?
Given the available data and momentum, ICICI Bank appears better positioned to deliver superior short-term returns, while HDFC Bank continues to offer stronger long-term stability.
Expert Opinions and Brokerage Recommendations
Brokerage calls include:
- ICICI Bank:
- Jefferies: Buy, Target ₹1,450
- Nomura: Outperform, Target ₹1,500
- HDFC Bank:
- Citi: Buy, Target ₹2,050
- Axis Securities: Hold, Target ₹1,920
Investor Psychology: FOMO or Calculated Bets?
Retail investors are often swayed by short-term gains, but seasoned investors are taking a more nuanced view—balancing between growth potential and risk appetite.
Historical Performance: Learning from the Past
Over the last 5 years, ICICI Bank has given 180% returns, while HDFC Bank delivered around 120%. Clearly, ICICI has shown better capital appreciation in recent times.
Asset Quality: Stability is Key
Both banks boast low NPAs, but ICICI’s better asset mix and provisioning make it more resilient during downturns.
Risks to Consider Before Investing
- HDFC Bank: Post-merger complexities, margin pressures
- ICICI Bank: High valuation risks, overbought indicators
Valuation Multiples: Are They Overpriced?
| Metric | HDFC Bank | ICICI Bank |
|---|---|---|
| P/E Ratio | 19x | 22x |
| P/B Ratio | 3.2x | 3.8x |
ICICI trades at a premium, reflecting higher expected growth.
Should You Diversify Between the Two?
Absolutely. Diversifying between both gives a blend of stability and growth. A 60:40 allocation in favor of ICICI could be ideal for aggressive investors.
FAQs About Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank
1. Why are shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank rising?
They’ve surged due to strong earnings expectations and robust sectoral performance.
2. Which bank is better for short-term returns?
ICICI Bank is currently more favored for short-term gains.
3. Is HDFC Bank good for long-term investment?
Yes, due to its stable fundamentals and strong deposit base.
4. When will the Q4 results be announced?
April 19, 2025 (Saturday).
5. Are both stocks overvalued now?
ICICI is nearing overbought levels; HDFC is relatively balanced.
6. Should I invest in both HDFC and ICICI?
Yes, for a diversified and risk-managed banking portfolio.
Conclusion: The Final Word on HDFC vs ICICI Bank Stocks
In conclusion, while both Shares of HDFC and ICICI Bank have hit impressive highs, ICICI Bank seems poised to outperform in the short-term due to its superior asset quality, digital push, and higher growth rate. However, HDFC Bank remains a solid long-term pick for those seeking consistency and dividends.
Whether you’re a risk-taker or a cautious investor, now’s the time to keep these banking giants on your radar.
Stay updated with all the insights.
Navigate news, 1 email day.
Subscribe to Qrius
