In the complex arena of Asian geopolitics, a dramatic shift is happening. Once seen as a future contender for global dominance, India is finally emerging as a significant force on the world stage. The latest Asia Power Index, released by the Lowy Institute, highlights this shift by ranking India third, following only the United States and China. This ranking is based on several factors, including military strength, diplomatic influence, resilience, and future resources.
India’s Power in Asia is Growing, China’s Plateauing Below US:
The Lowy Institute report sheds light on the larger power dynamics at play across Asia. While the United States and China still dominate the region, the report indicates that China’s power is stagnating due to economic challenges and structural issues. On the other hand, India’s power in Asia is on the rise, fueled by its growing diplomatic and economic clout.
So, what’s driving India’s ascent, and what does it mean for the future of Asia? Let’s dive into the details.
India’s Emergence in Asia:
For decades, India was seen as a nation full of potential but often lagging behind in realizing that potential. However, the 2024 Asia Power Index reveals a different story—India’s power in Asia is growing, while China’s influence seems to be plateauing below the US. This development is both significant and complex, with many contributing factors.
A New Contender in the Geopolitical Race:
India’s rise isn’t just a fleeting trend; it’s a structural shift in Asia’s power balance. Once viewed as an aspirational player, India is now firmly in the conversation when discussing major powers in the region.
China’s Plateauing Influence:
Despite China’s economic and military growth, its power is no longer surging. Slower economic growth, along with long-term structural challenges, means China’s influence in Asia is plateauing. According to the Lowy Institute, this stagnation is a result of economic flatlining, reducing the gap between China and its rivals.
The United States: Still Leading in Asia:
Even though China has made strides in military capability, the United States continues to lead in six out of the eight broad categories of power. While Beijing has improved its military readiness, it’s not enough to challenge America’s dominance.
India’s Military Might: A Growing Force:
For years, India’s military capability was seen as underdeveloped compared to regional giants like China. However, that narrative is rapidly changing. According to the 2024 Asia Power Index, India’s military strength now ranks third in Asia, trailing only behind the US and China.
Modernization of India’s Armed Forces:
India’s military modernization has been a cornerstone of its recent rise in power. From upgrading its navy to developing new missile systems, the country is focusing on becoming a formidable military force in Asia.
China’s Military Growth Slows:
While China’s military growth remains impressive, it has begun to slow down, allowing India to close the gap. This development is significant because it creates more room for India to assert its influence in the region.
Diplomatic Clout: India’s Non-Alignment Strategy:
One of the most important factors in India’s rise is its diplomatic influence. The Lowy Institute report credits Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s global leadership as a key reason for this growth.
PM Modi’s Global Strategy:
Under Modi, India has participated in a record number of diplomatic dialogues, especially with countries within Asia. The country’s non-aligned stance has helped it navigate tricky geopolitical waters, allowing it to strengthen its global standing without picking sides.
China’s Diplomacy Falters:
Conversely, China’s diplomatic reach is facing setbacks. The plateauing of China’s power is partially due to its aggressive foreign policy, which has alienated some of its neighbors and other global powers.
India’s Economic Growth: A Post-Pandemic Resurgence:
Economically, India is experiencing a resurgence, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. The 2024 Asia Power Index notes that India’s Economic Capability score increased by 4.2 points, a significant jump that highlights the country’s growing economic might.
Purchasing Power Parity and Economic Stability:
India’s economy is now the world’s third-largest in terms of purchasing power parity. This economic stability provides a solid foundation for India’s growing influence in the region, particularly as China’s economy slows down.
Future Resources: A Youthful Advantage:
India’s demographic dividend is another key factor contributing to its rise. With a young, growing population, India is positioned to reap the benefits of a large workforce, unlike China, whose population is aging rapidly.
The Lowy Institute on India’s Future:
The Lowy Institute report notes that India’s score in Future Resources increased by 8.2 points, thanks to its youthful population. This demographic advantage is expected to boost the country’s economic and military power in the coming decades.
Challenges Facing India’s Rise:
Despite these promising developments, India’s rise is far from guaranteed. The Lowy Institute points out several challenges that the country must overcome to fully realize its potential as a major global power.
Economic Integration:
India’s low level of economic integration with other Asian countries is one of the biggest hurdles. The report specifically mentions that India is losing ground in economic relationships, with Indonesia overtaking it in this metric.
Defense Networks and Security Cooperation:
Another area where India is struggling is in defense cooperation. The report highlights a decline in India’s Defense Networks score, driven by the country’s reluctance to deepen its security ties with the US and other regional allies.
Resilience: India’s Strength in Adversity:
While India’s rise is full of complexities, the country has demonstrated an impressive level of resilience. Its ability to bounce back from economic and geopolitical challenges sets it apart from other nations in the region.
India’s Diplomatic Influence in 2023:
In 2023, India’s diplomatic activity reached new heights, engaging in the sixth-highest number of dialogues among Asia Power Index countries. This increase in diplomatic efforts has solidified its position as a rising power.
Comprehensive Power: The Key Metrics:
India’s overall power is measured across a variety of factors, including military strength, economic capability, and diplomatic influence. While the country is still trailing the US and China, its comprehensive power is growing steadily.
Power Gap: A Work in Progress:
However, there remains a “power gap” between India’s projected influence and its actual ability to project power, particularly in regions east of the Malacca Strait. This gap suggests that while India has made significant strides, there’s still work to be done.
India’s Power in Asia is Growing, China’s Plateauing Below US: Lowy Institute Report:
According to the Lowy Institute report, India’s power in Asia continues to grow, with the country’s influence steadily increasing across multiple domains. However, China’s power is plateauing, largely due to economic challenges and an aging population. This shift creates opportunities for India to further assert its dominance in the region.
FAQs:
1. What is the Lowy Institute’s Asia Power Index?
The Asia Power Index is a comprehensive report that ranks countries based on various metrics, including military capability, diplomatic influence, and economic power.
2. How does India compare to China in the Asia Power Index?
According to the 2024 Asia Power Index, India is ranked third, while China’s power is plateauing, largely due to economic and demographic challenges.
3. Why is India’s power growing in Asia?
India’s rise is attributed to its growing diplomatic influence, economic strength, and military modernization, as highlighted in the Lowy Institute report.
4. What challenges does India face in becoming a major power?
India’s challenges include low economic integration with other Asian countries and a reluctance to deepen its defense partnerships.
5. How does China’s plateauing affect Asia?
As China’s power plateaus, opportunities arise for countries like India to increase their influence in the region.
6. What is India’s demographic advantage?
India has a young, growing population, while China’s population is aging, giving India a potential demographic edge in the future.
Conclusion: A New Balance of Power in Asia:
As the geopolitical landscape in Asia continues to evolve, the rise of India and the plateauing of China mark a significant shift in regional power dynamics. With its military modernization, diplomatic clout, and economic resurgence, India is poised to become a major player in the region. However, challenges remain, and India’s ability to overcome these obstacles will shape the balance of power in Asia for decades to come.
Stay updated with all the insights.
Navigate news, 1 email day.
Subscribe to Qrius
