When it comes to streaming platforms, Amazon Prime Video continues to surprise us with its diverse and ever-expanding film library. Unlike some streaming services that focus only on recent hits, Prime Video reaches far into the past, bringing back classic films alongside contemporary gems. In September 2025, the platform added several standout titles, and critics at Rotten Tomatoes have spoken.
So, which movies truly deserve your time? We’ve curated the 5 Best Prime Video Movies to Watch in September 2025, Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Score, offering a mix of fantasy, gothic horror, crime drama, supernatural thrillers, and timeless war epics. Whether you’re in the mood for an edge-of-your-seat thriller or a nostalgic classic, this list has something for everyone.
5 Best Prime Video Movies
Before we dive deeper into each pick, let’s quickly glance at the Rotten Tomatoes rankings for these five must-watch films:
| Rank | Movie Title | Year Released | Rotten Tomatoes Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Great Escape | 1963 | 94% |
| 2 | The First Omen | 2024 | 83% |
| 3 | Casino | 1995 | 78% |
| 4 | Crimson Peak | 2015 | 72% |
| 5 | Three Thousand Years of Longing | 2022 | 71% |
5 Best Prime Video Movies to Watch in September 2025, Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Score
Let’s break down each of these films and explore why they deserve a spot on your September streaming list.
1. The Great Escape (1963) – A Timeless War Epic
Why does The Great Escape still hold up after six decades?
Because it’s more than just a war movie—it’s a gripping tale of resilience, brotherhood, and courage under impossible circumstances.
Released in 1963, this World War II classic stars Steve McQueen, James Garner, Charles Bronson, James Coburn, and other acting legends. It dramatizes the real-life escape attempt of Allied prisoners from a German POW camp, though it takes creative liberties with history.
The narrative follows 250 prisoners plotting one of the boldest escapes in wartime history. The film balances humor, suspense, and tragedy, making it an unforgettable experience. The daring motorcycle chase scene with Steve McQueen remains iconic, symbolizing freedom against oppression.
Even today, its 94% Rotten Tomatoes rating reflects both critical acclaim and audience love. It’s not just a movie; it’s a cinematic milestone.
2. The First Omen (2024) – A Prequel Done Right
Can a horror prequel actually enhance its franchise?
Yes—and The First Omen is living proof.
This 2024 horror thriller takes us back before the events of the original The Omen franchise. Starring Nell Tiger Free, the film follows Margaret, an American novice who works in an orphanage. As she prepares to take her final vows as a nun, she uncovers a dark conspiracy orchestrated to bring forth the Antichrist.
What makes this movie stand out is its eerie atmosphere and strong character-driven storytelling. Unlike many horror prequels that fall flat, The First Omen was praised for its originality and world-building, earning an 83% Rotten Tomatoes score.
If you’re craving a supernatural thriller with a chilling storyline, this one should top your watchlist.
3. Casino (1995) – Scorsese’s Crime Masterpiece
Why is Casino considered one of Scorsese’s finest works?
Because it’s a brutal, stylish, and unflinching look at the underbelly of Las Vegas.
Directed by Martin Scorsese, Casino stars Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Sharon Stone. The story follows Sam “Ace” Rothstein, a mob-connected handicapper running a casino empire in the 1970s. But behind the glamour lies betrayal, corruption, and chaos.
Sharon Stone’s portrayal of Ginger McKenna earned her critical acclaim, and Joe Pesci’s menacing performance as Nicky Santoro is unforgettable. The movie captures the seductive allure of Vegas while exposing its dangerous undercurrents.
With a 78% Rotten Tomatoes score, Casino remains one of the greatest mob dramas of all time—raw, tense, and endlessly rewatchable.
4. Crimson Peak (2015) – A Gothic Love Story with Horror Undertones
Is Crimson Peak just another haunted house movie?
Absolutely not. This Guillermo del Toro creation is a gothic romance wrapped in ghostly terror.
Set in the early 20th century, the movie follows Edith Cushing (Mia Wasikowska), a young writer swept into a marriage with the mysterious Thomas Sharpe (Tom Hiddleston). Moving to his family estate—Crimson Peak—she soon realizes that the mansion hides sinister secrets, particularly involving Thomas’s sister Lucille (Jessica Chastain).
With its haunting visuals, lavish set designs, and spine-chilling atmosphere, Crimson Peak offers more than jump scares—it’s a gothic fairytale about love, betrayal, and madness. Though divisive upon release, it holds a 72% Rotten Tomatoes score, proving its value as an artistic and memorable horror romance.
5. Three Thousand Years of Longing (2022) – A Fantasy of Desire and Regret
What happens when George Miller takes a break from Mad Max?
You get a poetic fantasy drama like Three Thousand Years of Longing.
Starring Tilda Swinton and Idris Elba, the film tells the story of Alithea Binnie, a scholar who accidentally releases a Djinn from a lamp while in Istanbul. The Djinn offers her three wishes, but Alithea doubts his intentions. To convince her, he recounts three deeply personal tales of love, heartbreak, and regret spanning centuries.
With a 71% Rotten Tomatoes rating, the film may not be for everyone, but its thoughtful storytelling and emotional resonance make it worth watching. It’s a slower, more reflective fantasy that explores human desires in a way blockbusters rarely do.
Why Trust Rotten Tomatoes Scores for Choosing Movies?
Rotten Tomatoes has become a go-to benchmark for movie lovers worldwide. Its unique approach—aggregating reviews from critics and audiences—gives viewers a balanced perspective. While not flawless, its scores often reflect the overall consensus on a film’s quality.
If you’re pressed for time and wondering what’s worth watching, relying on Rotten Tomatoes ratings ensures you’re picking films that have been vetted by both experts and everyday audiences.
Prime Video vs Other Streaming Platforms: What Sets It Apart?
One of the best things about Prime Video is its eclectic catalog. While Netflix pushes original programming and Disney+ leans heavily on franchises, Prime Video offers a blend of new releases, classics, indie films, and international cinema.
This makes Prime Video a one-stop shop for all kinds of movie lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for a 1960s war epic or a 2020s horror prequel, you’ll find something binge-worthy.
FAQs About the 5 Best Prime Video Movies
1. Which movie on this list has the highest Rotten Tomatoes score?
The Great Escape (1963) tops the list with an impressive 94% score.
2. Are all these movies available on Prime Video worldwide?
Availability may vary depending on your region, but most major markets will have these titles.
3. Can I download these movies for offline viewing on Prime Video?
Yes, Prime Video allows offline downloads on supported devices.
4. What genre variety do the 5 Best Prime Video Movies cover?
They span war, crime, fantasy, gothic horror, and supernatural thriller genres.
5. Are there any new Prime Video exclusives releasing in September 2025?
Yes, alongside these classics and hits, Prime Video continues to drop new originals every month.
6. Which of these movies is best for family viewing?
The Great Escape is the most family-friendly option, while others like The First Omen may suit mature audiences.
Conclusion
Amazon Prime Video has truly outdone itself in September 2025 by offering an eclectic mix of films that cater to diverse tastes. From the timeless brilliance of The Great Escape to the chilling suspense of The First Omen, these five titles showcase why Prime Video is a powerhouse in the streaming industry.
So, if you’re wondering what to watch this month, let the 5 Best Prime Video Movies to Watch in September 2025, Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Score be your ultimate guide. Grab some popcorn, dim the lights, and get ready for unforgettable cinematic journeys.
